CG Policy · 2025
In this section7 topics
Corporate Governance Policy
Has a Corporate Governance Policy
Yes
Policy Description
Taokaenoi Food & Marketing Public Company Limited has been operating since 2004 and has experienced continuous development and growth. In 2015, the Company listed on the Stock Exchange of Thailand. In the past, the Company's growth has been in terms of market expansion, sales and profits, which have continued to grow. The Company exports its products to many countries around the world, as well as expanding its production capacity. However, due to changes in social conditions, people's lifestyles and economic conditions, both domestically and internationally, the Company has come up with the concept of developing the organization to grow sustainably together with stakeholders in every value chain.
The Company has established a corporate governance policy as a guideline for corporate governance. In 2024, the Board of Directors reviewed and improved the corporate governance policy to be in line with the principles of good corporate governance for listed companies in 2017 as the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) announced for the board of directors and employees to adhere to as a guideline for their operations, in conjunction with the Taokaenoi Code of Conduct with the aim of the company to grow sustainably in line with the company's vision, create good returns for shareholders, effectively respond to the expectations of stakeholders, and be transparent and fair to stakeholders.
Policy Document Link
https://investor.taokaenoi.co.th/misc/cg/20250324-tkn-cg-en.pdf
Policy & Practices — Board of Directors
Has Policy & Guidelines for the Board
Yes
Board Guidelines
| Guideline | Detail |
|---|---|
| Nomination of Directors | The Board of Directors has delegated the responsibilities to the Nomination and Remuneration Committee to establish and regularly review the structure of the Board, including its size, composition, diversity, and appropriate proportion of independent directors, to ensure alignment with the Company’s objectives and long-term goals. The Board of Directors is composed of individuals with diverse qualifications, encompassing a wide range of skills, experience, expertise, and specific attributes necessary to support the achievement of the Company’s objectives. A Board Skills Matrix is developed to ensure that the Board, as a whole, possesses appropriate and well-balanced competencies, enabling it to understand and effectively respond to the needs and expectations of stakeholders. The director nomination process involves a careful review of the backgrounds and qualifications of nominated candidates. Recommendations are submitted to the Board of Directors prior to proposing the appointments to the shareholders’ meeting for approval. Shareholders are provided with sufficient information on nominated candidates to support informed decision-making. |
| Determination of Director Remuneration | The Company has a policy to set the compensation for directors, sub-committee members, Chief Executive Officer, and senior executives at a level comparable to the Company’s performance in order to retain the required quality of personnel. The Company determines compensation according to the following guidelines:
|
| Independence of the Board of Directors from the Management | The Board of Directors establishes a Board structure that promotes diversity and an appropriate balance between executive and non-executive directors in order to support effective oversight and sound checks and balances. This structure enables directors to exercise independent judgment and freely express their views. The Chairman of the Board, who serves as an independent director, works in collaboration with the Managing Director in formulating the Board meeting agenda to ensure that matters of significance to the Company are duly considered. |
| Director Development | The Board of Directors places importance on ensuring that the Board and individual directors possess adequate knowledge and understanding of their roles and responsibilities, the Company’s business operations, and applicable laws and regulations. The Company supports the continuous development of directors’ competencies by encouraging regular participation in training and development programs relevant to their duties. Furthermore, directors are encouraged to attend training courses organized by the Thai Institute of Directors (IOD) and other relevant institutions throughout the year. The Company also provides an orientation program for newly appointed directors to equip them with essential information and a comprehensive understanding of the Company’s objectives, key goals, vision, mission, core values, as well as its business nature and operational approach. |
| Board Performance Evaluation | The Board of Directors shall conduct an annual performance evaluation of the Board, sub-committees, and individual directors through a self-evaluation process. The results of the evaluation shall be utilized for the continuous improvement of the Board’s structure, composition, and overall effectiveness in performing its duties. |
| Corporate Governance of Subsidiaries and Associated Companies | To control the subsidiary and associated companies, The Company has established the corporate governance policy for them with an aim to determine measures and mechanism both direct and indirect to enhance competency of the corporate governance and management of the subsidiary company and associated. Another purpose is to supervise and ensure that the subsidiary and associated companies comply with measures and mechanism set forth and in conformity with The Company policy as well as the public company law, civil and commercial code, securities law and related laws including relevant notifications, regulations and criteria announced by the Capital Market Advisory Board, Securities and Exchange Commission and the Stock Exchange of Thailand ("SET") Moreover, The Company has determined an investment policy for the subsidiary and associated companies to ensure conformity to the corporate governance principles and to be a guideline for investment in other businesses including to enhance competency to our business operation. Taokaenoi has established an investment policy in relevant business or similar business or the business that could generate return and support our business operation, and to strengthen our growth and operation result, or to invest in a business as a synergy to the Company. For example, being a source or sales channel, development center for alternative raw materials for our production. Nonetheless, the Board of Directors may consider investment in any business other than our core business or other business of the group in case it is considered that such business is potential and the investment will generate return to the Company and shareholders as a whole. The investment must be consistent and suit to the business situation, policy, goal and business growth direction and strategic plan of the Company. The consideration for an investment in any project will include the proportion of investment, expected profit, potential risks and financial status of the Company. The Company will determine investment analysis procedures before going forward with any project investment. Further details are as follows: 1.) The Company will send directors according to the proportion of shareholding in each company or top-rank employees to supervise the subsidiary and associated companies to ensure the same direction and to bring about the highest benefits to the Company. The Company should then have the Veto Right on important matters with which such subsidiary will proceed. Dispatching representatives from the Company who hold directorship in the subsidiary and associated companies must be approved by the Board of Directors in advance. Any investment must be approved by the meeting of the Board of Directors or meeting of shareholders (as the case may be). Moreover, approval for such investment must be consistent and conform to the notifications of the Capital Market Advisory Board, Securities and Exchange Commission and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. The investment in such company must pass an approval from the Board of Director. Every related transactions must be approved or consented to the Audit Committee. 2.) Any transactions or action of the subsidiary and associated company which is considered as related transactions as per notification of the related transactions or that considered or is an acquisition or disposal of assets according to notification of the acquisition or disposal of assets must obtain an approval from the meeting of the Board of Directors and/or approval from meeting of shareholders or approval from related authority as stipulated by law, before proceeding (as the case may be). The subsidiary and associated company must obtain an approval from the meeting of the Audit Committee before entering into any transaction or action (only the case of related transaction under notification of the related transactions), meeting of the Board of Directors and/or meeting of shareholders and/or related authority (as the case may be). The related transactions between the Company, subsidiary and associated company must conform to business reason, transparency, and must be available for audit at any time, and must be under the reasonable market price and supporting factors. Moreover, The Company must disclose such related transactions in a financial statement according to the auditing standard of the listed companies. The data disclosed includes data of both parties to prevent a conflict of interest and potential corruption. 3.) In addition, when entering into a transaction or occurrence of situation of the subsidiary company or associated company which causing requirement that The Company must disclose the information to the Stock Exchange of Thailand under the criteria set forth in related notification, the director or senior employees being a representative of The Company must notify the Management without delay, about the subsidiary's plan to proceed such transaction. The data storage and records of the subsidiary must be available for audit and retrieval for preparation of financial statement. 4.) The Board of Directors and executives of the subsidiary and associated companies have the duty and responsibility for disclosure of the information related to financial status and operation result to the Company. The notifications of the Capital Market Advisory Board, Stock Exchange of Thailand related shall apply mutatis mutandis. Moreover, the directors' interest and their related persons must be disclosed and submitted to the Company. 5.) The Company determines the necessary work and operation plan to ensure that the subsidiaries and associated companies disclose the information relating to operation results and financial status and other information to the holding company. The Company will take neccessary actions and monitors to ensure the subsidiary and associated companies have a system for disclosure of data and adequate internal control system for business operation. Moreover, The Company will monitor closely the operation result and situation of the subsidiary and associated companies. The analysis result including opinions or suggestions will be presented to the Board of Directors and the board of the subsidiary or associated companies for consideration to determine a policy or to improve for business growth and continual development of the subsidiary and associated companies. |
Code of Conduct
Has a Business Code of Conduct
Yes
Code of Conduct Description
The Board of Directors reviews the Company’s corporate governance policy on an annual basis. In 2024, the Company updated its corporate governance policy, which is the latest version, to align with the Corporate Governance Code for listed companies (2017) issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission of Thailand (SEC). This policy serves as a guideline for the Board of Directors and employees in their operations, alongside the Taokaenoi Code of Conduct (TKN Code of Conduct). The objective is to ensure the Company’s sustainable growth in line with its vision, deliver strong returns to shareholders, effectively meet stakeholders’ expectations, and uphold transparency and fairness toward all stakeholders. The details are as follows:
Corporate Governance
The Company adopts four key principles as the foundation for corporate governance:
Ethics : Conducting business with integrity and ethical standards.
Responsibility : Committing to efficient performance while ensuring accountability and transparency, fostering trust among stakeholders.
Equitable Treatment : Treating all stakeholders fairly and impartially.
Sustainable Value Creation : Enhancing corporate value alongside sustainable business development to ensure long-term benefits for the Company and its stakeholders.
Corporate Governance Practices
To align with good corporate governance principles, the Company adheres to the Principles of Good Corporate Governance for Listed Companies 2017, as issued by the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC). The Company follows eight key corporate governance principles:
Principle 1 Roles and Responsibilities of the Board of Directors
Principle 2 Establishing Company's Objectives and Key Goals for Sustainability
Principle 3 Enhancing an Effective Board of Directors
Principle 4 Selecting and Developing Senior Executives and Managing Human Resources
Principle 5 Encouraging Innovation and Responsible Business Practices
Principle 6 Ensuring a Proper Risk Management and Internal Control System
Principle 7 Maintaining Financial Credibility and Information Disclosure
Principle 8 Encouraging Shareholder Participation and Communication
Code of Conduct Link
https://investor.taokaenoi.co.th/misc/cg/20250324-tkn-cg-en.pdf
Code of Conduct Practices
| Guideline | Detail | Document Link |
|---|---|---|
| Prevention of Misuse of Inside Information | Prevention of Conflicts of Interest The Board of Directors has established a Conflict of Interest Prevention Policy based on the principle that all decisions related to Company transactions must be made in the best interests of the Company and its shareholders. Company personnel, including directors, executives, and employees, must not exploit their position within the Company to seek personal or affiliated gains, whether financial or otherwise. They must also avoid engaging in activities that may lead to conflicts of interest. Any business transactions, whether conducted personally or through an entity in which an individual has an interest, must be disclosed in accordance with the Company's regulations and reported to the Board of Directors. Directors, executives, and employees have a duty to safeguard the Company's legitimate interests, limiting their external engagements to the minimum necessary. The following guidelines apply:
| |
| Anti-corruption | The Company conducts its business with transparency and integrity, ensuring compliance with all relevant laws and standards. The Company has established and publicly declared its Anti-Corruption Policy, encouraging other companies and business partners to adopt and declare similar policies. Additionally, the Company maintains its membership in the Thailand Private Sector Collective Action Coalition Against Corruption (CAC) to enhance stakeholder and shareholder confidence. | |
| Whistleblowing and Protection of Whistleblowers | The Company places great importance on good corporate governance, transparency, and accountability. It provides employees with opportunities to report irregularities in the Company’s operations through dedicated channels and protection mechanisms. This ensures that whistleblowers and those providing information do not face retaliation or hardship, thereby serving as a positive example for society. The Company adheres to governance principles, ethical standards, and social responsibility to ensure fairness, transparency, and accountability in its business operations. It has established reporting channels for whistleblowing, complaints, feedback, or suggestions regarding any potential adverse impact on stakeholders or risks that may lead to damage to stakeholders, stemming from business operations or employee conduct involving violations of laws, ethical codes, fraud, unfair treatment, or negligence. Reports can be submitted through the following whistleblowing channels:
The aforementioned whistleblowing channels are secure and confidential, allowing whistleblowers, complainants, or individuals providing information to report wrongdoing or fraud and offer recommendations on compliance with anti-corruption measures with confidence. Complaints will be treated with the highest level of confidentiality, and whistleblowers may submit reports through multiple channels. They may choose to remain anonymous or disclose their identity to facilitate follow-up actions or provide additional details if necessary. The Company has established mechanisms and processes for recording, monitoring progress, resolving issues, and reporting stakeholder complaints. It ensures that multiple accessible complaint channels are available and publicly disclosed on the Company's website or in the annual report. The complaint handling process is as follows: Employees or stakeholders may report misconduct, submit complaints, provide feedback, or make suggestions through the designated channels. The Company will conduct an investigation following standard procedures, document the investigation in writing, and maintain confidentiality regarding the whistleblower’s identity. Appropriate protective measures will be provided for whistleblowers who report misconduct in good faith. The Company will also safeguard the confidentiality of complaint-related information to protect the whistleblower from potential repercussions. If the investigation confirms misconduct, an investigation committee will be established to determine the appropriate disciplinary actions. The findings and proposed penalties will be reported to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors for further action. | |
| Preventing the Misuse of Inside Information | To ensure fair access to information and prevent the misuse of internal information for personal benefit, the Company's policy applies to directors, executives, employees, and staff, including their spouses and minor children. As part of the Company's commitment to Good Governance, the Board of Directors has approved a policy governing the use of internal information as follows:
The Company has established disciplinary penalties for individuals who exploit or disclose internal information for personal gain or in a manner that could harm the Company. The severity of the disciplinary action will be determined based on the circumstances, including verbal warnings, written warnings, probation, or termination of employment—whether through dismissal, removal, or forced resignation. Additionally, the Company provides training for executives to ensure they understand their obligations, including reporting their securities holdings and those of their spouses and minor children who hold the Company’s securities. This training also covers the legal penalties under the Securities and Exchange Act. | https://investor-th.taokaenoi.co.th/misc/cg/20230727-tkn-inside-information-th.pdf |
| Prevention of money laundering | The Company strictly adheres to all applicable anti-money laundering laws and regulations. | |
| Giving or receiving gifts, entertainment, or business entertainment | The exchange of gifts, benefits, assets, services, entertainment, or hospitality in business dealings must adhere to local customs, traditions, and legal regulations. The value of such exchanges must be reasonable, align with the Company's Anti-Corruption Policy, and must not influence unfair decision-making. | |
| Compliance with laws, rules and regulations | The Company places great importance on compliance with all applicable laws, regulations, and regulatory requirements, both domestically and internationally. The Company adheres to principles of accuracy, transparency, and accountability in its business operations. Policies and practices have been established in alignment with relevant legal and regulatory frameworks, supported by appropriate corporate governance, internal control, and risk management systems. The Company also closely monitors changes in applicable laws and regulations to ensure ongoing compliance and to mitigate risks arising from non-compliance. In addition, the Company promotes awareness and understanding of legal and ethical standards among directors, executives, and employees at all levels, fostering a corporate culture grounded in integrity and responsibility toward all stakeholders. | |
| Use and maintenance of data and assets | The Company recognizes the importance of safeguarding its information and assets, including those of customers, business partners, and all stakeholders. The Company has therefore established policies and guidelines to ensure that information and assets are used appropriately and handled with due care. Confidential and sensitive business information must be protected and used solely for legitimate business purposes. Such information must not be used for personal benefit or disclosed to unauthorized parties. With respect to assets, directors, executives, and employees at all levels are required to use the Company’s assets efficiently, responsibly, and strictly for business purposes. They are also responsible for ensuring that such assets are properly maintained and protected from damage, loss, misuse, or unauthorized use. The Company has implemented appropriate internal control systems and security measures to prevent unauthorized access, use, or disclosure of information and assets. | |
| Anti-competitive | The Company upholds fairness, integrity, and transparency in its business operations and does not engage in unfair competitive practices. The Company ensures that all business competition is conducted ethically and in compliance with relevant laws and regulations. | |
| Cyber security | The Company places high importance on safeguarding information and information technology systems to mitigate risks arising from unauthorized access, use, alteration, or disclosure of data. Appropriate information security policies and measures have been established, covering access control management, data classification, data backup procedures, cybersecurity protection, and continuous monitoring of abnormal activities. The Company also regularly reviews and assesses information technology risks and continuously enhances its internal control measures to address evolving threats and technological changes. In addition, the Company promotes awareness and understanding of information security among directors, executives, and employees at all levels to prevent and minimize potential impacts on business operations and stakeholders. | |
| Environmental management | The environment is essential to human survival and sustainable growth. As a manufacturer and distributor of snack products derived from natural ingredients, the Company recognizes that global environmental changes directly impact the quality of raw materials and packaging. The Company conducts environmental impact assessments before implementing any operations and designs processes that minimize environmental impact through the use of appropriate technology. The Company also takes measures to protect and restore biodiversity affected by its business activities, properly manage waste disposal and emissions, and monitor greenhouse gas emissions. Additionally, the Company fosters a culture of environmental awareness, ensuring that all employees incorporate eco-friendly practices into their daily operations. | |
| Human rights | The Company places great importance on fundamental human rights, promoting respect for individual rights and freedoms by ensuring non-discrimination for all people. The Company actively supports equality, without distinction of gender or social class, and firmly commits to not engaging in or supporting businesses associated with human rights violations. The Company ensures fair and equal treatment of employees by providing benefits that meet or exceed legal requirements, maintaining workplace safety and hygiene, and offering training and career development opportunities. Employees are encouraged to enhance their skills in various areas, and fair compensation structures are established. Additionally, the Company strictly complies with labor laws and internal regulations to ensure just and equitable treatment of all employees. | |
| Occupational health and safety | The Company places strong emphasis on occupational health and safety for employees, contractors, and all relevant parties. The Company is committed to conducting its business under policies that prioritize accident prevention, risk reduction, and the promotion of a healthy workplace. Appropriate safety measures have been established in compliance with applicable laws and relevant standards, including regular risk assessments, hazard control measures, and continuous improvement of the working environment. In addition, the Company provides regular training and awareness programs on occupational health and safety for employees. Safety performance is monitored, reviewed, and reported to prevent and reduce work-related accidents and illnesses. The Company’s objective is to maintain a safe, hygienic, and supportive working environment that enhances operational efficiency and sustainable business performance. |
Promoting Compliance with the Code of Conduct
Promotes Compliance by Directors, Executives and Employees
Yes
Description
The Company has established the Code of Conduct as a fundamental framework guiding its operations. The Code and related policies are communicated comprehensively to directors, executives, and employees at all levels through orientation programs, regular training sessions, and internal communication channels, in order to foster awareness, understanding, and strict adherence.
Anti-Corruption Networks & Projects
Joined or Declared Intent to Join Anti-Corruption Networks
Yes
Networks & Projects Joined
| Network / Project | CAC Certified |
|---|---|
| Thai Private Sector Collective Action Against Corruption: CAC | Y |
| United Nations Global Compact (UNGC) | |
| Participation of anti-Corruption networks and initiatives |
Material Changes & Developments in CG
Reviewed the CG Policy or Board Charter in the Past Year
Yes
Material Changes or Developments in the Past Year
Yes
Policy Review — Description
Over the past year, the Company has reviewed and revised its corporate governance policies and practices, including the charters of the Board of Directors and its subcommittees, to ensure alignment with good corporate governance principles, applicable laws, and relevant regulations, as well as to ensure their appropriateness for the Company’s current operations. In addition, the Company has communicated these policies and practices to executives and relevant departments and has continuously monitored their implementation in order to support effective corporate governance.
Implements the CG Code for Listed Companies
Yes
CG Code — Description
The Company has adopted the Corporate Governance Code for Listed Companies (CG Code) in accordance with the guidelines prescribed by the Office of the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) to govern its corporate governance practices. The Board of Directors places importance on transparent and accountable corporate governance while taking into consideration the interests of all stakeholders. The Company has established relevant policies, practices, and charters to support compliance with such principles. In addition, these policies and practices are regularly reviewed to ensure their appropriateness and alignment with applicable laws, regulations, and best practices for listed companies on the Stock Exchange of Thailand.
Other CG Performance & Outcomes
Practices to Promote Shareholders’ Rights
Summary of the 2025 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders (AGM)
The summary of the Minutes of the 2025 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders can be viewed at the following link https://investor.taokaenoi.co.th/misc/shareholder-meeting/agm2025/20250509-tkn-agm2025-minutes-en.pdf |
In 2025, the Company held the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders in a physical meeting format only on Friday, 25 April 2025 at 1:00 p.m. at Jupiter Rooms 12–13, 1st Floor, Challenger Building, IMPACT Muang Thong Thani, Ban Mai Subdistrict, Pak Kret District, Nonthaburi 11120. During the year, the Company did not convene any Extraordinary General Meeting of Shareholders. The date for determining the list of shareholders entitled to attend the meeting (XM) was 20 March 2025. For the 2025 Annual General Meeting of Shareholders, the Company conducted the meeting as follows:
The Company provided an opportunity for minority shareholders to propose agenda items and nominate qualified candidates for election as directors in advance of the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders during the period from 1 November 2024 to 30 December 2024. Shareholders wishing to propose agenda items must be either a single shareholder or a group of shareholders holding the Company’s shares as of the proposal date and collectively holding not less than 5% of the total voting rights of the Company. The Nomination and Remuneration Committee will review and screen the proposed agenda items and director nominations before submitting them to the Board of Directors for further consideration and subsequently proposing them to the Shareholders’ Meeting for approval. However, in 2025, no shareholders proposed any agenda items and/or nominated any candidates for consideration for election as directors prior to the Shareholders’ Meeting.
Prior to the Annual General Meeting of Shareholders, the Company disclosed the Board of Directors’ resolution regarding the convening of the meeting, including the date, time, and agenda items, through the information disclosure system of the Stock Exchange of Thailand (SET) to ensure that shareholders were informed in advance and had sufficient time to prepare for attending the meeting.
The Company also delivered the notice of the meeting through Thailand Securities Depository Co., Ltd., the Company’s securities registrar. The notice of meeting clearly specified the meeting agenda, relevant supporting information necessary for decision-making, the Board of Directors’ opinions, the minutes of the previous meeting, the annual report, and related meeting documents, as well as documents required for proxy appointment and procedures for granting a proxy as prescribed by the Company. In addition, the Company facilitated shareholders who were unable to attend the meeting in person by allowing them to appoint an independent director of the Company as their proxy to attend the meeting and vote on their behalf. The Company also provided convenience for shareholders who wished to use a proxy form in paper format, whereby shareholders could request such documents via email at ir@taokaenoi.co.th , and the Company would arrange for delivery through the channel specified by the shareholders. The notice of meeting was delivered to shareholders at least 14 days prior to the meeting date, having been sent by post on 25 March 2025. On the same day, the Company also published the notice of meeting together with the supporting documents on the Company’s website, allowing shareholders sufficient time to review the information in advance.
In addition, the Company provided shareholders with the opportunity to submit questions regarding the meeting agenda in advance of the meeting date, allowing the Company to compile relevant information and prepare comprehensive clarifications. Shareholders were able to make inquiries or submit questions regarding the shareholders’ meeting through the Company’s Investor Relations Department via email at ir@taokaenoi.co.th Prior to the commencement of the meeting, the Company clearly explained the voting procedures, voting methods, and vote counting process for each agenda item to the shareholders. Furthermore, this Annual General Meeting utilized a barcode system for registration and vote counting to facilitate shareholders attending the meeting and to ensure that the voting process and voting results for each agenda item were transparent and verifiable. The Company counted votes from shareholders who approved, disapproved, or abstained for each agenda item. The Chairman of the meeting asked shareholders or proxies whether there were any who disagreed with or abstained from voting on each agenda item and requested those who disagreed or abstained to raise their hands so that the staff could collect their voting cards before the closing of voting for that agenda item. The staff then collected and processed the voting results after the meeting was completed. For shareholders who appointed an independent director as their proxy, the Company cast votes in approval, disapproval, or abstention according to the shareholders’ instructions. In agenda items where a director had a conflict of interest, such director was requested to leave the meeting during the consideration of that agenda item. In addition, the Chairman of the meeting provided shareholders with the opportunity to freely express their opinions, suggestions, or questions on each agenda item before voting, ensuring that shareholders received sufficient information and details.
The Company appointed a legal advisor, Kudun and Partners Limited, to supervise the meeting and verify the vote counting process to ensure compliance with applicable laws and the Company’s Articles of Association, as well as to act as an observer at the vote counting station. A total of 8 directors attended the meeting, representing all 8 directors of the Company.
The Company subsequently disclosed the resolutions of the shareholders’ meeting, including the voting results for each agenda item, through the SET Link system of the Stock Exchange of Thailand and on the Company’s website at www.taokaenoi.co.th/ir on 25 April 2025. The minutes of the meeting, which comprehensively recorded the proceedings, including questions, clarifications, and opinions of shareholders, were also published on 9 May 2025.

